The Mystery of Flying Honeydew

Lantern bug (Enchophora sanguinea) expelling a jet of honeydew droplets [Canon 1Ds MkII, Canon 100mm macro, 2 speedlights Canon 580EX]

Although my entomological interests focus on katydids and other orthopteroid insects, a few years ago I started paying a closer attention to lantern bugs (family Fulgoridae), large insects remotely related to cicadas, which feed on plant nutrients that flow inside tree trunks. Lantern bugs have very long, stiletto-like mouthparts, which allow them to pierce the bark and tap into a rich stream of juices in the plant’s vascular tissue known as the phloem. This liquid is exceptionally rich in sugars, but it also contains small quantities of proteins and minerals, and it is mostly the last two that the insects are interested in. Consequently, lantern bugs end up with a huge surplus of water and carbohydrates in their diet, which they need to get rid off, and they do so by producing copious amounts of a sugary liquid known as honeydew. Other insects, such as aphids and scale insects, also produce honeydew, and they expel it slowly, in large droplets that accumulate at the tip of their abdomen. This makes it easy for other animals, ants especially, to come and lick it off – after all it would be a shame if all this sugar went to waste. Often, in return for the sweet treat, ants defend their “cattle” from predators.

Two species of blattodeans (Eurycotis spp.) collecting honeydew from the same lantern bug individual [Nikon D1x, Sigma 180mm, flash Nikon SB-28DX]

But until recently a similar relationship was not known to occur between lantern bugs and other animals. The reason was simple – unlike aphids, which produce a slow, easy to collect stream of honeydew, lantern bugs shoot honeydew out of the abdomen as a jet of tiny droplets that fall a great distance away from their bodies. I was able to measure the speed with which the honeydew was expelled by these insects, and it turned out to be between 0.8 and 1.7 m/sec (2.6-5.6 ft/sec.) No animal, it seemed, was capable of tapping into this nutritious but elusive resource – imagine trying catching beer cans flying with the speed of 60 miles/hour (if we adjust for differences in size and taste preferences.)

Moth (Euclystis proba) with a freshly caught droplet of honeydew on its proboscis. [Canon 10D, Canon 100mm macro, MT-24EX twin light]

Now we know, however, that the story is far more interesting. Together with my friend Kenji Nishida, a great Japanese entomologist and photographer, we have discovered that there exists an entire suite of organisms with unique behaviors that allow them to collect lantern bugs’ honeydew. We did our work in Costa Rica, primarily in the lowland to mid-elevation rainforest of the Atlantic part of the country. We discovered that there was a number of species of blattodeans (fascinating cousins of praying mantids and termites), who tapped the abdomen of lantern bugs with their front legs or maxillary pals, and were rewarded with a stream of honeydew that went directly into their mouths. The most astonishing part of this behavior was that occasionally we would see two or three blattodeans of different species forming a line behind a single lantern bug, patiently waiting for their turn! This unexpected politeness makes a lot of sense: a commotion of large insects fighting for access to a lantern bug would very likely spook the shy and skittish animal, and in the end nobody would get anything.

Lantern bug with two simultaneous moth guests (small Platynota sp. and larger Elaeognatha argyritis) [Canon 10D, Canon 100mm macro, MT-24EX twin light]

We documented a similar behavior in several species of moths, another group of frequent visitors to lantern bugs. The moths were able to catch individual, flying droplets of honeydew with their long proboscis and, like the blattodeans, sometimes formed a well-mannered line behind the insect.

Every now and then we would see a lonely ant looking wistfully at a lantern bug, but ants are simply too small to be able to catch the fast-flying honeydew, and never did we witness them being able to feed directly on the jet of honeydew droplets. We assumed that this bountiful source of sweet pee was forever beyond their reach. As it turned out, we were wrong. But to find out how ants manage to get the lantern bugs’ honeydew you will need to tune in tomorrow for the exciting conclusion of “The Mystery of Flying Honeydew!”

Update: Read the conclusion of the mystery.

12 thoughts on “The Mystery of Flying Honeydew

  1. Thanks so much for the profoundly interesting posts– your photos are incredible!– but what I find even more impressionable are the biological interpretations that you provide. I am a casual observer of insects here at my home in Brazil, and your site has given me greater insight into their behaviors. ~ peace, Jason

  2. Pingback: The Mystery of Flying Honeydew: A Strange Case of Unabashed Thievery | The Smaller Majority by Piotr Naskrecki

    • Terry,
      These insects can bee seen all over Costa Rica in the lowlands, up to about 500 m a.s.l., but I did most of the work on lantern bugs at La Selva Biological Station near Puerto Viejo de Sarapiqui (La Selva is a place definitely worth visiting, see it if you have a chance.) To find the lantern bugs you need to go out at night and look for them on tree trunks, sooner or later you will spot them.

  3. Pingback: The Week on Sunday | Splendour Awaits

  4. Pingback: Lantern bugs in action | The Smaller Majority by Piotr Naskrecki

  5. Pingback: Lantern bugs in action | The Smaller Majority by Piotr Naskrecki

  6. Dear Piotr,
    I work at the Natural History M useum London and I am producing a book on all aspects of leafhoppers which inlcudes information on honey dew. Do you have any pictures of leafhoppers in a similar situation to the fulgorids or any other interesting pictures that could be used in the book?
    Lois Obrien has told me that you have a picture of a snail catching honey dew, is this true?
    Kind regards,
    Mick

  7. Pingback: African Tuesday: Being bark | The Smaller Majority by Piotr Naskrecki

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s